Issue 39

One Month after Intercept: Debris Analysis from Russian ASAT Operation

LeoLabs’ one-month analysis of the Cosmos 1408 ASAT breakup found evidence consistent with a non-hypervelocity intercept and long-lived debris risk.

20 Dec 2021: LEO Labs published its third article with analysis from the 15 Nov 2021 Russian Nudol intercept of Cosmos 1408. Using its array of S-band radars, LEO labs has identified ~400kg of debris, or about 23% of the original mass of Cosmos 1408. Evidence points to a non-hypervelocity (<6km per second) collision which would generate larger, but fewer, pieces of debris. Regardless of the speed of the intercept, LEO Labs estimates the statistical probability of collision for satellites with mission-terminating debris in the 300–800km altitude range has likely doubled due to this event, and will remain high for many years.

– The number of Cosmos 1408 debris fragments is close to 500, and will certainly continue to rise in the coming weeks and months.

– There are 9 pieces of debris with Radar Cross Sections >1M^2. These larger objects are consistent with large appendages of the Cosmos 1408 spacecraft (4 antennas, 2 solar arrays, and several booms) that likely would have been left intact (or largely intact) from this event.

– The larger pieces of debris account for ~400kg of the original 1,750kg mass of Cosmos 1408.

– Using the typical value for trackable debris fragments of 0.10 m²/kg produce ~2,700 more fragments to account for the additional 1,350kg (total mass estimate from debris would equal the pre-event estimate of ~1,750 kg).

– The total number of smaller (<10cm) fragments were created remains unknown. These fragments constitute mission-terminating collision risks but are not reliably cataloged.

– LeoLabs will start to catalog previously untracked sub-10cm debris starting in 2022, and is deploying multiple additional S-band radars around the world over the next 12–24 months.

LEO Labs analysis continues to lend credence to a non-hypervelocity impact encounter. Such an intercept results in fewer fragments but ones that are likely longer-lived (due to their larger mass) than “typical” collision-induced fragments. The only way to mitigate this risk is to catalog these fragments, and track them accurately and frequently to produce actionable conjunction alerts for satellite operators.