Issue 39

Limits of China-Russia Space Cooperation

A Modern War Institute article argued that mistrust, technology-transfer concerns and asymmetric resources limit deeper China-Russia space cooperation.

15 Dec 2021: Recent article in the Modern War Institute notes that there remain significant obstacles to China-Russia space cooperation. Russian fears of Chinese technological theft and the prospect of playing second fiddle to China will continue to strain the relationship. Moreover, Russia’s ASAT test demonstrates that Russia is willing to jeopardize China’s space interests when doing so serves Russian ones.– China and Russia have a long yet complicated relationship when it comes to space. At the very outset of its space program, China benefitted from Soviet assistance, including receiving technical advisors and even an out-of-date R-2 ballistic missile that China reverse engineered, and that would evolve into China’s Long March rockets. – As Sino-Soviet relations deteriorated, China’s space program could no longer rely on Soviet assistance, but had to instead focus more on indigenous development.– Today, the China-Russia relationship is driven by an alignment of interests and an attempt to balance the more militarily powerful United States. As the US military relies the most on space technologies to project power globally, Russia and China are incentivized to develop capabilities to negate these advantages.– There are important fault lines in the Russia-China relationship, ranging from nationalism to mistrust. These elements pose significant obstacles to further integration and coordination between Russian and Chinese space programs.– In the 1990s, Russia felt burned when China undercut Russian profits by reverse engineering its space technology. More recently, in 2019, Russian state conglomerate Rostec accused China of copying a wide range of Russian military hardware.– China has more resources to contribute for future projects including the planned lunar base ; and will be concerned that Russia could free ride on Chinese contributions in future projects.