Issue 97

How To Survive a Solar Storm

Issue 97 explains how the extreme May 2024 geomagnetic storm affected auroras, satellite drag, GPS and space operations, while comparing it with the Carrington Event.

15 May: Judging from the amazing images from as far south as Florida, there were quite a few people who noticed the recent geomagnetic storm that occurred 11-12 May 2024. The very southerly appearance of the Northern Lights (aurora borealis) was a result of a massive cluster of sunspots ~17x the width of the Earth releasing at least seven powerful Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) in Earth’s direction. Below are excerpts from a recent article released in the Payload Space daily newsletter (recommend subscribing…they have some great stuff, to include their Pathfinder podcast!)

– The Sun is at the peak of an ~11-year cycle that began in 2019. That means we’re seeing more solar activity than usual. More frequent solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs) = more concentrated radiation flowing from the Sun to Earth = more disruption of the Earth’s magnetic field.

Aurora observed during the May 2024 geomagnetic storm.
@CatholicArena via X

– The Earth’s magnetic field can generally deflect the bulk of the solar wind, but this <the weekend CMEs> powerful series of bursts got through to interact with the upper atmosphere.

– Oxygen, nitrogen, and other elements in that upper atmosphere were ionized by the radiation, leading to glowing, southern-reaching auroras.

– This solar activity also tends to make the atmosphere puff up, increasing drag on satellites—particularly ones in LEO.

Aurora during the May 2024 geomagnetic storm.
@PezmanWx via X

– Though the storm hasn’t brought down any satellites or fried any essential systems that we know of, there were minor disruptions to some services, and many operators chose to pause normal operations. NOAA told NPR that there were disruptions to GPS, but nothing life-threatening for the mission.

-That puffing of the atmosphere meant that satellites had to work harder than usual to maintain their altitude and keep themselves pointing in the right direction. ESA shared a graph of the power usage of the orbit control system on its Sentinel 2 satellite, which spiked during the storm:

ESA graph of Sentinel-2 orbit-control-system power usage during the geomagnetic storm.
ESA Graph of Sentinel 2 Satellite Power Usage (payloadspace.com)
Aurora observed at unusually low latitude during the May 2024 storm.
@albertdrosphoto via X

– Starlink, as a whole, also muddled through the storm intact, per an Elon tweet. In 2022, increased drag caused by a CME forced 38 Starlink satellites to deorbit within days after they were launched, before they had reached their operational altitude. There’s been no such incident this time around, though the birds were “under a lot of pressure.”

Aurora image from the May 2024 geomagnetic storm.
@EdPiotrowski via X

While not mentioned in the Payload Article the solar activity of 11-12 May was nothing compared to what occurred in September 1859 in what has become known as the “Carrington Event.” (See Video).

Aurora over a coastal lighthouse during the May 2024 storm.
@photographmaine via X

From the New York Times on 10 May 2024:

– It is the strongest such storm to reach Earth since Halloween of 2003. That one was strong enough to create power outages in Sweden and damage transformers in South Africa.

– The solar activity is so powerful that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which monitors space weather, issued an unusual storm watch for the first time in 19 years, which was then upgraded to a warning.

– A geomagnetic storm watch or warning indicates that space weather may affect critical infrastructure on or orbiting near Earth. It may introduce additional current into systems, which could damage pipelines, railroad tracks and power lines.

Aurora forecast graphic associated with the May 2024 G5 storm.
@vcdgf555 via X

– The most notable solar storm recorded in history occurred in 1859. Known as the Carrington Event, it lasted for nearly a week, creating aurora that stretched down to Hawaii and Central America and impacting hundreds of thousands of miles of telegraph lines.

– NOAA classifies these storms on a “G” scale of 1 to 5, with G1 being minor and G5 being extreme. The most extreme storms can cause widespread blackouts and damage to infrastructure on Earth. Satellites may also have trouble orienting themselves or sending or receiving information during these events.

Reported Starlink outages during the geomagnetic-storm period.
@cordyceps12 via X

– The current storm is classified as G5, or “extreme.” It is caused by a cluster of sunspots — dark, cool regions on the solar surface — that is about 16 times the diameter of Earth. The cluster is flaring and ejecting material every six to 12 hours.

– More flares and expulsions from this cluster are expected, but because of the sun’s rotation the cluster will be oriented in a position less likely to affect Earth. In the coming weeks, the sunspots may appear again on the left side of the sun, but it is difficult for scientists to predict whether this will cause another bout of activity.